Cash Signal Intact as of Close of Friday, November 16

.
By most common measures the markets are oversold and we should be considering entering.  Nothing at this point is indicating that we should move in, and with a short week due to Thanksgiving, I anticipate lower demand in the markets which will cause a general drift of prices.  The analogy is a sailboat without a keel -- you can go a specific direction, but you may also do it sideways ...

Since the sell signal that was effective with the close of November 2nd and which we could have acted on with the close of prices on the 3rd, we have the following market performance:

F-Fund (bonds):  Up +0.18%
C-Fund (mimic S&P500):  Down -3.87%
S-Fund (mimic small cap stocks):  Down -4.46%
I-Fund (mimic international index): Down -2.70%

We've been in cash so we've edged up a whopping +0.04%, which does not keep up with inflation in case you were wondering.  This is better than losing the amounts above, so net-net, we're up on this particular call.

The broad markets peaked on September 14th -- easy to know in hindsight, impossible to know when you're in the middle of the forest.  Since that time we have had the following market performance:


G-Fund (cash): Up +0.23%
F-Fund (bonds):  Up +1.18%
C-Fund (mimic S&P500):  Down -6.87%
S-Fund (mimic small cap stocks):  Down -8.11%
I-Fund (mimic international index): Down -5.44%

Obviously the call to cash on October 10th, a move back into the 16th, and the call to cash on November 2nd helped save some capital, but we did lose some ground compared to November 2nd close:

The trades on November 5th were for a loss, lowering system performance across the board.  Our actual numbers are different than what is above because the above values assume 25% in each fund and in reality, I provide guidance on allocations that I use which are different than 25% in each fund.

If you are not owning a government-sponsored retirement fund but want to proxy into using exchanged traded funds (ETFs), there is a parallel universe:  GGT, using liquid ETFs that mimic the S-Fund (VXF), C-Fund (SPY), I-Fund (EFA), and F-Fund (AGG) has a better behavior overall for the past year, but note that the system is solidly in cash with the exception of the F-Fund (AGG)/bonds, which did signal long back on November 8th at an execution price on November 9th of $16.0324 (F-Fund) and limit buy of $112.14 (AGG).  F-Fund closed at $16.0348 on November 16th, for a gain of +0.01% (yes, 1/100th of a percent), and AGG at $112.21, for a gain of +0.06%.

In my view being long in bonds (F-Fund or AGG) is hardly worth the effort.  They can't go much higher in value since rates are so low.

Here's GGT's view of the TSP proxy ETFs:

Right-click on the image to open it in a new tab or window.

Most short-term market corrections fall in the 4-6% range.  We're a bit below that in the C and S funds, so to state that we're going to get a rebound and set new highs in the market is too optimistic.  I expect a rebound off the bottoms here, but I also anticipate possibly not entering into the markets until December.

I'll send notes out to the board if the behavior changes.  I'm watching both the GGT system and my independent TSP timer on a daily basis, and will post any relevant behavior.  Don't rely on me though -- do your own diligence, subscribe to my dropbox folder to get the ETF status on a daily basis, and you can make your own decisions without me posting here.

Regards,

pgd